The AR-15 platform, a staple in the world of modern firearms, has seen countless iterations and modifications over the decades. While many modern builds favor the sleek, low-profile look of a flattop upper receiver, the AR-15 with a carry handle remains a popular choice for shooters, collectors, and enthusiasts. This configuration offers a unique blend of nostalgia, functionality, and a distinct aesthetic appeal. This article delves into the history, advantages, and disadvantages of the carry handle AR-15.
A Blast from the Past: The History of the Carry Handle
The carry handle upper receiver wasn't just a design choice; it was a fundamental component of early AR-15 and M16 rifles. Integrated directly into the upper receiver, it housed the rear sight, providing a sturdy and reliable aiming solution. This design was born out of military necessity, offering a built-in sighting system that minimized the need for additional accessories and simplified maintenance. The original design, dating back to the Vietnam War era, reflects the robust nature of military-grade weaponry.
Advantages of the Carry Handle AR-15
While modern flattop uppers offer greater flexibility in optic mounting, the carry handle design still presents several compelling advantages:
Built-in Sighting System: Reliability and Simplicity
The most obvious advantage is the integrated, rugged rear sight. This eliminates the need for separate rear sight purchases and mounting, saving both money and time. The carry handle's rear sight is typically robust and reliable, capable of withstanding the rigors of use. It's also inherently zeroed to the front sight, simplifying the process for rapid target acquisition.
Enhanced Strength and Durability: A Solid Foundation
The carry handle's incorporation into the upper receiver creates a more rigid and structurally sound platform compared to some flattop designs. This can be particularly beneficial for users who prefer a more durable firearm.
Nostalgic Appeal and Collector Value: A Piece of History
For many shooters, the carry handle AR-15 represents a classic design aesthetic that evokes the history of the platform. This nostalgic appeal, combined with their potential collector value, makes them attractive to a significant segment of the firearms community.
Disadvantages of the Carry Handle AR-15
Despite its advantages, the carry handle AR-15 also presents some drawbacks that modern shooters should consider:
Limited Optic Mounting Options: Restricted Versatility
The most significant drawback is the limited ability to mount optics. While some solutions exist, such as using a carry handle-mounted optic or using a rail system that attaches to the carry handle, these often compromise the clean aesthetics of the design and may not be as versatile as flattop systems.
Weight: Added Bulk and Heavier Feel
The integrated carry handle adds weight to the firearm compared to a flattop model. While the weight difference might be negligible for some, it can become noticeable during extended use.
Potential for Obstruction: Interference with Optics or Accessories
The carry handle can interfere with the use of certain accessories or optics, especially those with taller profiles.
Conclusion: Weighing the Pros and Cons
The decision to choose an AR-15 with a carry handle depends heavily on individual preferences and priorities. For shooters who value reliability, simplicity, and the classic aesthetic, the carry handle design remains an appealing option. However, those who prioritize optic versatility and a lightweight build might find a flattop upper more suitable. Ultimately, understanding the advantages and disadvantages will help any shooter make an informed choice that aligns with their shooting needs and style.
