The carry handle AR-15. For some, it's a nostalgic throwback to the weapon's origins, a symbol of a simpler time in firearms. For others, it's a potentially practical and aesthetically pleasing option in a world of increasingly complex optics and accessories. This post delves into the pros and cons of choosing a carry handle AR-15, exploring its history, functionality, and place in the modern shooting world.
A Blast from the Past: The History of the Carry Handle
The carry handle upper receiver was the original design for the AR-15 platform. Integrated directly into the upper receiver, it housed the rear sight and provided a convenient way to carry the rifle. This design was prevalent in military and early civilian models. The simplicity and robustness of this design contributed to its widespread adoption. Before the advent of readily available Picatinny rails and modularity, the carry handle was simply the way to mount your sights.
Functionality and Advantages of a Carry Handle AR-15
While seemingly outdated, the carry handle upper offers several advantages:
-
Simplicity and Reliability: Fewer moving parts mean fewer points of potential failure. Carry handle uppers are known for their ruggedness and reliability, a significant factor for those prioritizing dependability over cutting-edge features.
-
Co-Witnessing with Low-Power Optics: While not ideal for high-magnification scopes, a carry handle upper allows for co-witnessing with low-power optics like red dots mounted on a lower 1/3 co-witness mount. This provides a backup sighting system should the optic fail.
-
Ergonomics: Some shooters find the carry handle's integrated design provides a more comfortable and natural cheek weld, especially when using iron sights.
-
Weight Savings (Sometimes): Depending on the specific build, a carry handle upper might offer slight weight savings compared to a flattop upper with added accessories like a rail system and backup iron sights.
Disadvantages and Considerations
Despite its nostalgic appeal and certain advantages, the carry handle AR-15 also comes with drawbacks:
-
Limited Mounting Options: The lack of a Picatinny rail on top severely limits the versatility of accessories. Mounting anything beyond iron sights requires creative workarounds and potentially compromises on functionality.
-
Sight Picture: The carry handle's relatively high sight picture can be less comfortable or intuitive for some shooters, especially those accustomed to a lower sight picture offered by flattop uppers.
-
Weight Distribution: The weight distribution can feel different compared to a flattop, potentially impacting handling and shooting dynamics for some users.
The Carry Handle AR-15 in the Modern World
Today, the vast majority of AR-15s utilize flattop uppers, allowing for greater flexibility in mounting optics and accessories. However, the carry handle continues to hold a niche appeal. It's a solid choice for those who prioritize simplicity, reliability, and a classic aesthetic. It can also be a cost-effective option, as carry handle uppers are often less expensive than their flattop counterparts.
Conclusion: Choosing the Right Upper
Ultimately, the decision of whether to choose a carry handle AR-15 depends on individual needs and preferences. Weigh the advantages of its simplicity and reliability against the limitations of its accessory mounting options. Consider your shooting style, intended use, and budget before making your choice. For those seeking a retro feel or a reliable, no-frills platform, the carry handle upper remains a viable and potentially attractive option. For those prioritizing maximum versatility and accessory options, a flattop upper is generally the more practical choice.
