Choosing between a Glock 19 and a Glock 17 often comes down to personal preference, but a key consideration is magazine compatibility. This detailed comparison explores the similarities and differences between the two, focusing specifically on their magazines.
Understanding the Glock 17 and Glock 19
Before delving into magazine specifics, let's briefly recap the core differences between these popular handguns. The Glock 17 is a full-size, 9mm pistol known for its reliability and capacity. The Glock 19, on the other hand, is a compact version, offering similar reliability in a more concealable package. This size difference is a major factor affecting magazine design and capacity.
Magazine Compatibility: The Key Question
The crucial point regarding Glock 17 and 19 magazines is that they are not fully interchangeable. While there's some overlap, there are important distinctions to understand:
-
Glock 17 Magazines in a Glock 19: Generally, a Glock 17 magazine will not fit into a Glock 19. The 17's longer magazine is simply too long for the 19's grip. Forcing it could damage the firearm.
-
Glock 19 Magazines in a Glock 17: This is where things get a little more nuanced. A Glock 19 magazine will fit into a Glock 17. However, there will be a noticeable gap between the bottom of the magazine and the grip. This gap doesn't affect functionality in most cases, and many users successfully utilize Glock 19 magazines in their 17s, especially for concealed carry where a shorter, flush-fitting magazine is preferable.
Capacity Differences: A Practical Consideration
The magazine capacity difference is another significant factor. Glock 17 magazines typically hold 17 rounds (hence the name), while Glock 19 magazines usually hold 15 rounds. Extended magazines are available for both models, offering even higher capacity. The choice between 15 and 17 rounds is largely a matter of personal preference and intended use. For concealed carry, the slightly lower capacity of the Glock 19 magazine might be a benefit.
Beyond Capacity: Other Magazine Considerations
Beyond capacity and fit, several other factors influence magazine selection:
- Material: Glock magazines are typically made from durable polymer, but different generations of magazines might use slightly different materials.
- Baseplates: Different baseplates can affect the magazine's grip and overall length. Extended baseplates are common accessories for increasing capacity.
- Reliability: While generally reliable, individual magazines can vary in their performance. Some users may experience occasional feeding issues with certain magazines, irrespective of the pistol model.
Choosing the Right Magazine: A Practical Guide
Ultimately, the "best" magazine depends on your specific needs and preferences. Here's a simple guide:
-
Glock 17 Owner: Stick with Glock 17 magazines for full capacity. Glock 19 magazines can be used for concealed carry scenarios, but the gap will be noticeable.
-
Glock 19 Owner: Use Glock 19 magazines for optimal fit and concealability. Using a Glock 17 magazine is not recommended.
-
Consider Extended Magazines: Both Glock 17 and 19 models can benefit from extended magazines, offering additional capacity for range use or specific situations.
Conclusion: Understanding the Nuances Matters
The Glock 17 and Glock 19 are both excellent pistols, but their magazine compatibility isn't entirely straightforward. Understanding the differences in fit and capacity is crucial for making informed decisions about magazine purchases and ensuring optimal performance. Prioritizing reliability and a comfortable grip will lead to a safer and more enjoyable shooting experience. Remember to always practice safe gun handling and consult with a firearms professional if you have any questions or concerns.
