Choosing between the NVIDIA Shield TV (2017) and the NVIDIA Shield TV 2019 (often referred to as Shield 2.0) can be tricky. Both offer powerful streaming and gaming capabilities, but several key differences exist that might sway your decision. This comprehensive comparison will highlight the pros and cons of each, helping you choose the best Shield for your needs.
Design and Aesthetics: Subtle but Significant Changes
While both models boast a sleek and compact design, the 2019 Shield boasts a more refined aesthetic. Its slightly smaller footprint and more subtle design integrate seamlessly into most entertainment setups. The 2017 model, while still attractive, feels a bit larger and more noticeable. The remote also received a significant upgrade in 2019, incorporating a more ergonomic design and improved button placement.
Processing Power and Performance: A Generational Leap
The most significant difference lies in the processing power. The 2019 Shield packs a more powerful Tegra X1+ processor compared to the Tegra X1 in the 2017 model. This upgrade translates to smoother performance, particularly when handling demanding 4K HDR content and graphically intensive games. You'll notice a considerable difference in loading times and overall responsiveness with the newer model. While the 2017 model still performs admirably, the 2019 Shield offers a noticeably superior user experience.
Memory and Storage: More Room to Play
The 2019 Shield also offers options for increased memory and storage. Depending on the configuration, you can choose between models with more RAM and internal storage, allowing you to download and play more games or store a larger library of media. This is a significant advantage for users who plan on heavily utilizing the gaming capabilities or storing extensive media collections locally.
AI Upscaling: Enhanced Picture Quality
The 2019 Shield introduces AI-powered upscaling, a feature absent in the 2017 model. This technology significantly enhances the visual quality of lower-resolution content, bringing it closer to 4K resolution. While not a true 4K replacement, the upscaling technology provides a noticeable improvement in sharpness and detail, making even older content look more vibrant and detailed.
Connectivity and Features: Minor but Noticeable Improvements
While both models offer robust connectivity options including HDMI, Ethernet, and USB, the 2019 Shield benefits from some minor improvements. These improvements are less impactful than the processor upgrade but still contribute to the enhanced overall user experience.
Price and Value: Weighing the Investment
The 2019 Shield typically commands a higher price than the 2017 model. However, the added performance, features, and refined design often justify the price difference. If you prioritize the latest technology and improved performance, the investment in the 2019 model is worthwhile. The 2017 model, however, remains a capable device, offering excellent value for users on a budget and who are less concerned with the latest features.
Conclusion: The Right Shield for You
Ultimately, the best choice depends on your individual needs and budget.
Choose the NVIDIA Shield 2019 if:
- You prioritize the latest technology and performance.
- You want AI-powered upscaling for improved picture quality.
- You need more storage and RAM for gaming and media.
- You value a more refined design and improved remote.
Choose the NVIDIA Shield TV (2017) if:
- You're on a tighter budget.
- You don't require the latest processing power.
- You don't plan on heavily using the gaming capabilities.
By carefully considering these factors, you can confidently select the NVIDIA Shield that best meets your entertainment and gaming requirements.
